Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tim O'Neill's avatar

Look, I just started because of the quality of research, obvious background knowledge, and fluid style of the writing of the one article I read. However, with this survey I already feel the outcast. You asked: Am I a liberal or a progressive? I laughed. No, I am a die in the wool Republican . . . short for liberal, oriented toward the values of the Enlightenment. Also, a fiscal conservative, for the smallest government we can agree to; a cultural traditionalist --- for instance, pro-life (but not enforced with criminal penalties). So am I a neo-liberal, a hybrid, or an outcast from your domain? I ask because I view government as the necessary evil, easily corruptable to meet whatever ideas are fashionable to the elites of the day. List the major themes on any imbecilic Fox news broadcast and I will agree with them 90% of the time. Enemy or potential friend?

Expand full comment
javiergarcia's avatar

Something I would really like to read your thoughts about is about the following 3 topics:

1) Make a dual comparation of Madagascar vs eastern/southern africa and Madagascar vs the Malay World/philippines/indochina and which comparison is more apt in which levels.

2) I have not yet completed your ethiopia series but I would like to know if the pre-Saleise ethiopia was closer economically to medieval europe or to islamic arabic world. The slavery part pushes towards an arabic similarity while the peseant and central monarchy path pushes towards christian europe.

3) A South Africa-Brasil or South Africa-Argentina comparison could be interesting

Regarding your questions: your article about corruption as low-middle income issue changed totally my perspective. And I believe your bias is a "modernity is here, development is more or less obligatory and we are in a single highway towards the future" which is very economist of you (I say that as a fellow economist), like I don´t know if Iran or Saudi Arabia are in the same highway, or Japan, or Belarus. Worst war of the century was GWOT but of the decade Ethiopia-Sudan are tied.

Greetings from bolivia

Expand full comment
30 more comments...

No posts